“ Eye eye captain! If you're into seafood on bread then shiver me timbers and look no further because X marks the spot on this hidden treasure chest. You walk in and it has the feel of a "no frills" brewery meets an artsy sandwich shop. We went for lunch and didn't get drinks so I won't be reviewing that portion of the menu. My problem was that I'm not very adventurous when it comes to seafood so I struggled a little bit with what to select. I ended up choosing The Encantado, which is a fried fish sandwich with aioli sauce. I had them put that on the side so I could dip my toe in the water. It was an excellent choice and I ended up wishing I had an extra portion of the sauce. Prices were fair and the atmosphere was cool. The food came out a little slow but not too bad. I would go here again, especially to try out some of their drinks as they had a pretty expansive list to choose from. ”

“ The triton fries is the true star of the show. Worth the money and the hype. The reason my rating is 4 stars instead of 3. The sandwich is whatever. 3/5 for me. Not that garlic-y and not spicy, it tasted more tomatoe-y than anything. i felt like I was eating tomato soup in a sandwich.. but the bread is great haha.. would return for the fries and the fries only. ”

“ Their ambiance is very cool. Scallop Bacon Chowder was awesome! Big chucks of scallops, veggies and bacon in the soup. Good sandwich. Big shrimps and the bread was delicious. Their fries were bomb! Crispy outside! The sauce came with the plate was so good! Creamy, slightly spicy and garlicky! ”

“ Seafood lover or not, this place really does a good job at preparing their food to not smell and taste fishy . I highly recommend the garlic noodles, super buttery and garlicky. The sandwiches I got (named in order of the pics) were Nessie, Siren, and Griffin. Personally I think the Nessie was the best, it was perfectly seasoned and the fish of the day that I got was mahi mahi. I also ordered the Triton fries and I do wish the fries were skinnier, though they were light and crispy so that was redeeming with all the toppings. I love loaded fries so this was right up mu alley! ”

“ This place is definitely worth a try. I think the roll was a tad dry but I'm gonna give it a pass because it wasn't lobster season. I will definitely be revisiting during season. I'm lazy but I guess I'll try to be more descriptive. The roll is a fun shape, it's a fat loaf of bread with a chunk taken out of the center so it like a Minecraft taco if that makes any sense. It is really fluffy and definitely nice quality, and they butter it really well before toasting it. I feel like the cutout is not deep enough so you have a really thick chunk of just bread at the bottom which is not my favorite decision but it lets the roll stand up on its own which is nice for pictures I guess. The sauces are really good if a bit heavy. It comes with shrimp chips which are really good and seasoned really nicely. The fries are really good, nicely sauced and the scallops were very tender and overall make for a nice complement. It's a lot of food, nice to share as a side but aren't big like carne asada fries so don't order them to be a meal. This place is good. 4 stars ”

“ I popped by for a very late lunch on a Wednesday and was surprised to see that a couple other tables were also filled. It is somewhat casual in that you order at the cash register before seating yourself, but the food is nice enough that I would still call this a solid date night location. Additionally, Supernatural is located in a plaza with a huge parking lot, which is always a plus. Pricing wise, it definitely isn't super budget friendly for the portion size for the most part, but seafood is typically expensive anyways and on that scale this is relatively affordable. I do want to point out that they make their own shrimp chips here and I was super hyped to try them, but honestly they tasted exactly like store bought ones: good, but not any noticeable difference surprisingly. Siren Sandwich (4/5): This was very solid as the shrimp is cooked perfectly so there's a bite, but it isn't chewy in any way. Plus, the bread is incredibly fluffy, but was griddled so it's buttery and has a slight crunch when you bite into it. My only complaint would be I wish the ratio of shrimp to bread was slightly higher and I wish there were a few more vegetables inside. Triton Fries (4.25/5): If you're looking for the best bang for your buck, I would say this one is it. The fries are cooked super well: fluffy inside and crunchy enough on the outside to withstand all the sauces and toppings. They are super generous with the seafood and it is COVERED in scallops and shrimps for less than twenty bucks. The sauces are of course amazing as well, the only slight issue would be it can get a little heavy, but if you're sharing it's perfect! ”

“ Review number 2! Came back to try another sandwich. Got the Aphrodite without bacon. Bread was amazing but it gets soggy pretty quickly on one side, so eat it fast! My first bite was amazing. The tomatoes balanced the richness that comes from the abundance of cheese. A bite without the tomatoes, however, it starts to feel a little too heavy. A little more acidity, and this sandwich would be perfection. O! Pay for sauce on the side! You won't regret spreading it on the sandwich for an extra kick. ”

“ Delicious sandwiches! Great lunch option and convenient parking available. If you dine in, they have a self service station with takeout boxes, utensils and condiments ready for you. The space is very open and bright, with a full bar area. The Lobster sandwich was $28 (6/2023) but absolutely packing with lobster meat, and the Siren Sandwich had a lot of mini scallops, but also more breading. I'd say shrimp chips over fries, but perhaps because the fries were greasy. ”

“ Phenomenal food, lots of great sea food and very fresh! Fun atmosphere with TVs and beer on tap. Perfect to watch a game or for a quick lunch. You order at the counter get a number and they deliver it to your table. All sandwiches come with these shrimp chips that have a great seasoning and small kick to them. Most of there sandwiches are with the catch of the day that changes each day and always very fresh. Only negative is they do not have many options that are not fish. ”